concerned veterans for america

Flogging

A part of the Bill of Rights, the 8th Amendment to the US Constitution was ratified on 15 Dec 1791. It says, “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” And on 5 Aug 1861, the US Army abolished flogging; the US Navy had abolished it 10 years earlier. For you non-floggers, flogging is when the person-to-be-punished is tied to a tree or ship’s mast or something similar and then is beaten with a rope (sometimes knotted) or leather whip (cat of 9-tails) or the like. So, since the Army did this for 70 years after the passage of the 8th Amendment, clearly flogging did not fall into the category of “cruel and unusual punishment.” Now-a-days, pouring some water up one’s nose (water-boarding) totally freaks some people out—they think it’s terrible. Maybe terrible (I’ve never been water-boarded) but not unconstitutional. A thought: maybe our prisons wouldn’t be so crowded if there was some unpleasant (but constitutional) punishment used there. And maybe our nation would be a bit safer if we could pour some (constitutionally correct) water up a few foreign terrorist noses (since when to foreigners not in the US have any of our rights anyway?).

Join the discussion

Further reading

blog soldier sanding in front of american flag

Movie of the Month for June

Troops, your viewing assignment for June is to watch the short film The Elevator. A short comedy film by Greg Glienna, the creator of Meet the...

blog soldier sanding in front of american flag

Movie of the Month for May

Troops, your viewing assignment for the month of May is to watch the short film The Life of Death. After you watch the film, email your thoughts and...

blog soldier sanding in front of american flag

Movie of the Month for April

Troops, your viewing assignment for April is to watch the coming-of-age short film Forever Tonight. Indian-American teen Lekha sneaks out of the...

Get Denny's Newsletter

Receive news and updates from Denny