berry law firm va disability lawyers

The forgotten US Constitution

Here’s a question that’s going around these days. Does anyone read the US Constitution? American lawyers don’t read it. Federal Judge Susan Bolton apparently has never read it. Same goes for US Attorney General Eric Holder. Here are some comments from a lawyer who has read it; the point is pretty clear.

“Article III, Sec. 2, clause 2 says:”In all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, and those in which a State shall be Party, the Supreme Court shall have original Jurisdiction. In all the other Cases before mentioned, the Supreme Court shall have appellate Jurisdiction.”
In other words, the Judge in the Arizona case has absolutely no Constitutional jurisdiction over the matter upon which she ruled. As the Constitution makes abundantly clear, only the U.S. Supreme Court can issue rulings that involve a state. So, neither Judge Bolton nor the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco, to which the case is being appealed, have any legal standing whatsoever to rule on the issue.
One wonders why, then, that US Attorney-General Eric Holder filed the federal government’s lawsuit against the state of Arizona in a court that has no authority to hear the case. Is this malicious or merely incompetence? And when is someone going to raise this issue?

Join the discussion

Further reading

blog soldier sanding in front of american flag

Movie of the Month for December

Troops, your viewing assignment for December is not a movie, documentary, or short film. Instead, US Navy Admiral William H. McRaven, one of the most...

blog soldier sanding in front of american flag

Movie of the Month for November

Troops, your viewing assignment for the month of November is to watch Mr. Overton. Meet Richard Overton, America’s oldest veteran at 109 years...

blog soldier sanding in front of american flag

Movie of the Month for October

Troops, your viewing assignment for October is to watch the award-winning CG animated short film Migrants. This one is definitely going to create a...

Get Denny's Newsletter

Receive news and updates from Denny